Heat pump vs PNG boiler: running cost comparison for Indian plants, 2026

• 7 min read • Comparison • Updated 13 October 2026
A piped natural gas fired packaged boiler in an Indian factory, showing the gas meter set, burner and insulated steam header
The comparison depends on two prices you already know: what one unit of gas heat costs you, and what one unit of electricity costs you

If you are running a PNG-fired boiler today, the first question is simple: what COP does a heat pump need to match your gas cost? In most Indian states the answer is 1.0 to 1.2. In other words, the heat pump only has to give a little more than one unit of heat for every unit of electricity it consumes, and it will cost the same to run as your boiler.

Actual machines do much better than that. Measured performance under Indian conditions is approx. 2.26 at 110°C output and 2.0 at 120°C, and the COP is higher still at lower temperatures. On the gas side, industrial PNG was ₹68/SCM in Gujarat and ₹75/SCM in the Morbi ceramic cluster in June 2026, whereas two years back Morbi was paying ₹44.68/SCM.

So for hot water and process heat below 100°C, the heat pump comes out well ahead. You can check this for your own plant with one division: your electricity tariff divided by what one useful kWh of gas heat is costing you.

What COP is needed to beat a PNG boiler?

Between 1.0 and 1.2, depending on your state and your contracted gas rate.

This figure has nothing to do with any particular machine. It is simply the ratio between two prices which you are already paying, i.e. what one useful kWh of heat costs you from gas and what one kWh of electricity costs you. Any heat pump which crosses this ratio will be cheaper to run than the boiler it replaces, and every point of COP above it is additional saving.

Against measured performance, the gap is quite large. Independent measurements under Indian conditions show approx. 2.26 at 110°C and 2.0 at 120°C, and these are at the difficult end of the range. In a typical PNG-fired plant most of the heat load is well below 120°C (hot water, wash baths, jacketed vessels etc.), where the achievable COP is higher and the margin over breakeven is even more.

Industrial PNG prices in 2026

WherePriceAs ofRemarks
Gujarat, general industrial₹68/SCMJune 2026Current industrial benchmark
Morbi ceramic cluster₹75/SCMJune 2026Cluster premium on the same fuel
Morbi₹44.68/SCMJuly 2024Two-year baseline; use this as your downside case

If you compare the first and third rows, it is clear that industrial gas has not seen a temporary spike which will settle down. The base price itself shifted two years back and has remained at that level since.

The reason is outside the control of any Indian buyer. Industrial PNG is priced on imported LNG and not on administered domestic gas, and Asian spot LNG was USD 21.38/MMBtu on 31 July 2026. So a boiler running on a gas contract linked to this benchmark is effectively exposed to the global LNG shipping market, which is a risk most plants do not realise they are carrying. We have covered the market background in more detail in our article on gas dependence and factory heating.

Why is the PNG price in the news lower than what my plant pays?

Because the rates you see published are mostly domestic (household) rates, and your plant is not on a household rate.

Price aggregator websites show Mumbai at ₹51.50/SCM and Gujarat at ₹46.82 to ₹55.79/SCM. These are domestic PNG rates for homes. The industrial rate in the same city is contract-specific and considerably higher; in Gujarat it was ₹68/SCM in June 2026.

Interestingly, using the household rate makes the heat pump look worse than it actually is. It understates your present fuel cost, and hence the saving also gets understated. In case someone has shown you a comparison based on ₹51.50/SCM, the calculation is understating your saving.

Be careful with policy news also. Administered-price gas is allocated to CNG and domestic PNG, not to industrial supply. So when the newspapers report that domestic PNG prices have been reduced, the same does not apply to the gas going into your boiler.

How to calculate your delivered cost per kWh of heat

There are four steps. Two of the inputs are already given on this page, and the other two you can take from your own bills and records.

StepWhat you needCommon mistake
Find your delivered gas cost per useful kWh of heatYour contracted rate per SCM, the calorific value of your contracted gas, and your boiler efficiencyMixing GCV and NCV. Take the calorific value and the boiler efficiency on the same basis, otherwise the result is meaningless
Find your electricity tariff per kWhYour bill, including demand charges, fuel surcharge and electricity dutyTaking only the energy charge in place of the landed rate. The difference between the two is large enough to change the decision
Divide the second figure by the firstThe two figures aboveUsing the household PNG rate in place of your industrial contract rate
Compare the result with the COP achievable at your output temperatureThe output temperature of the duty you actually want to shiftComparing the top-end COP with the top-end temperature. Both do not occur together

The result of step 3 is your breakeven COP. If it is lower than the COP achievable at your duty temperature, the heat pump will pay for itself on running cost alone.

The full method, with the same calculation applied to boilers in general, is given here. The same steps can be used for a furnace oil boiler, a diesel boiler or a thermic fluid heater, in case you are firing any of these along with gas. Our calculator will do the division for you.

Which electricity tariff should be used?

Use the landed rate and not only the energy charge. The landed rate varies from state to state much more than most buyers expect.

State and licenseeCategoryEnergy chargeDemand chargeLanded
Maharashtra, MSEDCLHT-I₹8.44/kVAh₹650/kVA/monthAdd duty and any time-of-day adjustment
Gujarat, GUVNLHT-I₹4.30/unitNot separately verified₹7.50 to ₹8.50 all-in
Tamil Nadu, TANGEDCOHT industrial₹7.50/kWh₹608/kVA/monthPlus 5 percent electricity tax
Karnataka, BESCOM and the other ESCOMsHT-2(a)₹6.70/unit plus 35 paise surcharge₹365/kVA/monthAbout ₹7.05 before duty
Uttar Pradesh, UPPCLLMV-6, Small and Medium Power₹9.02/unit average billing rateNot verifiedAlready all-in

Please note two points regarding this table. Firstly, the Uttar Pradesh figure is for LMV-6 (Small and Medium Power) and not for a large HT industrial connection, so it should not be taken as the rate a big plant would pay. Secondly, Maharashtra bills HT-I consumers per kVAh and not per kWh, so a plant running at poor power factor will pay more per useful unit than ₹8.44 suggests. If your PF is low, it is better to correct it before doing any calculation.

The Maharashtra row has one more useful point for anyone planning a few years ahead. The regulator has approved a reducing HT-I tariff path, from ₹8.44/kVAh in FY2026-27 to ₹7.45/kVAh by FY2029-30. So in one of the largest industrial states in the country, the electricity price is on a published downward path, whereas the gas price is linked to an imported commodity, and this is something you can verify from the tariff order itself.

What if gas prices come down again?

Almost every buyer asks this, and it is a fair question, so let us look at it properly.

For a realistic low case, we take ₹44.68/SCM, which was the actual industrial rate in Morbi in July 2024. This is not an assumption; gas was actually sold at this price.

At a lower gas price, the breakeven COP goes up and the margin reduces, but the heat pump still remains cheaper to run. The margin reduces fastest at the top of the temperature range, where the measured COP is around 2.0 at 120°C. At lower output temperatures, where most hot water and washing loads are, the reduction is much smaller. So a plant shifting a 70°C load and a plant trying to go up to 120°C are in quite different positions on this.

There is also a supply-side reason why gas returning to that level should not be taken as the base case. Export capacity was lost, and it will take years to rebuild. Indian manufacturers have responded by shifting to shorter, monthly gas agreements. On a monthly contract there is no forward price visibility at all, either up or down, and that itself is a reason to shift part of the load onto electricity, which is priced by a published tariff order.

Will a heat pump reach my process temperature?

It will cover some of your loads but not all, and it is important to be clear about this split at the start.

Within range: wash and pre-treatment baths, CIP circuits, jacketed vessels on aqueous duty, hot water loops and feed preheating. In most gas-fired plants these loads are a bigger share of the fuel bill than expected. When a boiler generates high-temperature steam only to heat an 80°C bath, most of that temperature is wasted.

Out of range: saturated steam at pressure, curing ovens and drying ovens. These will continue on your existing system.

Hence in most PNG plants the practical outcome is a partial changeover. The heat pump takes the low-temperature loads, and the gas boiler is retained for the balance load and as a standby, at least for the first year. Your gas bill comes down, but it will not become zero.

We supply air source, water source and cascade configurations for this kind of retrofit. You can find more details on the equipment and integration here.

What else changes apart from the fuel bill?

Four things, and two of them have a direct money value.

  1. IBR may no longer apply to that loop. A hot water circuit below 100°C is not a registered boiler under the Indian Boiler Regulations, so the certified attendant on every shift and the annual inspection shutdown are not required for it. Above 100°C this does not apply, so check it against the actual duty you are shifting.
  2. Gas infrastructure is no longer your headache. The gas connection, chimney and flue gas handling go along with the boiler.
  3. Your electrical load goes up, and this is the point which catches most plants. Shifting from fuel to electricity increases your sanctioned load, and exceeding it attracts charges which most plants have not budgeted for. The security deposit is also revised as per your new average billing, so a higher monthly bill means a bigger deposit at the next revision. Check your headroom before you budget the project, not after.
  4. Price risk shifts. You move from a fuel priced on LNG shipping to one fixed by a state tariff order, which has real value if you quote fixed-price jobs months in advance. Also check the tax and scheme provisions applicable before you commit capital.

How to check this for your plant

Start with our calculator, which needs your gas rate, electricity tariff and output temperature. If the breakeven COP it gives is lower than the COP achievable at your duty, the next step is to study your actual load profile, before going in for a quotation. You can share your details with us here and our team will get in touch.

Frequently asked questions

What COP is required to beat a PNG boiler?
In most Indian states a COP of 1.0 to 1.2 is sufficient. This is simply the ratio of your electricity price per kWh to your delivered gas cost per useful kWh of heat, so it will change with both prices and with your boiler efficiency.
Is a heat pump cheaper than gas at today's prices in India?
Yes, on running cost for loads below 100°C, and by a good margin. Industrial PNG in Gujarat was ₹68/SCM in June 2026. Measured heat pump performance under Indian conditions is approx. 2.26 at 110°C output, which is well above the breakeven of 1.0 to 1.2.
What happens if gas prices come down?
The margin reduces, but the heat pump still remains cheaper to run. For a realistic low case, take ₹44.68/SCM, which was the Morbi industrial rate in July 2024. The reduction is maximum at the top of the temperature range, and much smaller at the lower output temperatures where most process hot water loads are.
Can a heat pump replace a gas-fired steam boiler?
It cannot replace a boiler that is generating saturated steam at pressure. What it can replace are the low-temperature loads which the steam boiler is presently serving inefficiently, and in most plants these are a sizeable part of the fuel bill. The steam boiler continues for the duties which actually need steam.

Would you like us to run the comparison for you?

Tell us the fuel you use and the temperature your process needs. We will work out what the same heat would cost from a heat pump at your own prices and send the working back to you.

Or email us your fuel and electricity bills and we will work it out from those.